Your pizza night starts here

One pizza for the table. Another for the people who always want an extra slice. Our New York-style, hand-tossed pizzas are made for the way Lexington does dinner: together.

Order Online via Toast

Choose pickup or delivery and your available time on Toast.

A pizza topped with pepperoni, vegetables, and melted cheese on a serving tray at Elizabeth’s Pizza

Big slices. Big plans.

Find your kind of pizza.

Keep it simple with cheese, pick your own toppings, or start with one of these combinations from our menu.

Cheese & your choice of toppings

Small, medium or large. Cheese starts at $11.25, $12.25 and $13.99 respectively; add your preferred toppings on Toast.

All Meat

A hearty mix of pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, Canadian bacon, and hamburger.

Special

Pepperoni, sausage, and bacon meet green peppers, mushrooms, and onions.

Veggie

Black olives, green peppers, tomatoes, spinach, mushrooms, onions, and eggplant.

White

Alfredo sauce with mushrooms, tomatoes, and spinach. A different direction for pizza night.

More to explore

Find BBQ Chicken, Hawaiian, and Steak Pizza alongside the classics on the full menu.

Choose sizes, options, and current prices when you order.

See the full menu on Toast

Pizza and sauced wings pictured in an Elizabeth’s Pizza owner-posted promotion

Make it a meal

Give your pizza some company.

Add fried wings and homemade ranch or blue cheese for a table that has a little of everything. Garlic bread with cheese is another easy choice for the middle of the table. Feeding a bigger group? Explore the delivery and pickup specials on Toast before building your order.

Order Online via Toast

Before you order

Good questions. Quick answers.

What sizes and prices are available?

Cheese pizza is listed in small ($11.25), medium ($12.25) and large ($13.99). Baby Pizza and a 12-inch cauliflower crust are separate menu choices. See the full menu for specialty starting prices, and confirm your size and toppings on Toast.

Can I choose my own toppings?

Yes. The menu includes cheese pizza and options for one or more toppings. Select a size and see the available additions on Toast before checking out.

Are there pizzas without meat?

Cheese, Veggie, and White pizzas are listed on the menu. For allergies or specific dietary requirements, call the restaurant to discuss ingredients and preparation before ordering.

Where can I see pizza prices and specials?

Open our Toast menu for current prices, sizes, and delivery or pickup specials. Availability and ordering times are confirmed there as you build your order.